Falling in love with a teen heartthrob in the 90s was a right of passage. We all did it. We all had that one star who made our hearts flutter as we clumsily tumbled into puberty. Though we shared a lot of crushes with our friends, it turns out that your zodiac sign could indicate which one would have been your soulmate.
Sure, the 90s may be over and we no longer have Teen Beat Magazines plastered all over our walls, but it’s still fun to imagine which of your former favorite heartthrobs should have been your one true love.
Aries: Leonardo DiCaprio
You are ambitious and driven, so you need someone who can keep up with you. The best match for you would be Leonardo DiCaprio. He’s always up for a challenge, but he’d also be supportive of your goals.
Taurus: Joseph Gordon Levitt
You are stubborn and persistent with a lot of creative ideas to the problems you see in the world, so you need someone who can help you solve them. Don’t worry, you’ve got Joseph Gordon Levitt on your side and he’s going to be able to help you save the world.
Gemini: Rider Strong
You are so clever and funny that you need to have someone who can hold their own. Rider Strong is your teen heartthrob, because his charisma (and that hair) is all your really need in a crush.
Cancer: Jared Leto
You need to feel like you are taking care of someone, and for that reason, Jared Leto is your best choice. He needs all the love and support that you have to offer, and can appreciate all the things you do for him.
Leo: Freddie Prinze Jr.
You need someone who wants to go out and have fun with you and go experience all the world has to offer. Your creative energy is going to mesh well with Freddie Prinze Jr., because while he can have fun in a group setting, he’s also creative enough to keep your attention.
Virgo: Paul Rudd
You like to be organized and practical, but you also want someone who can be fun and witty. You need to be able to have your moments where you are independent, and Paul Rudd is willing to give you that, but when you come back together he’s always ready to make you smile.
Libra: John Stamos
You like to keep the balance, and John Stamos is the one who’s going to help you do it. His ability to give great advice and calming talks is a perfect counterpart for your diplomatic endeavors.
Scorpio: Heath Ledger
You are confident and bold and you need someone who can avoid being bulldozed by your personality. You and Heath Ledger would be perfect together because you both have strong senses of self.
Sagittarius: Justin Timberlake
Your innovative ideas need a creative counterpart who can challenge you and keep your life fun. Justin Timberlake will give you all the creativity you crave while also making sure you get to go out and socialize when you want to.
Capricorn: Jonathon Taylor Thomas
You love to be in charge, and your ideal heartthrob who is someone who is happy to let that happen. Jonathon Taylor Thomas is your best second in command, because he can help you accomplish your goals and he would never hold you back.
Aquarius: Mark Paul Gosselaar
Your imagination is one that needs a partner who is capable of keeping up with their own collection of ideas. You are always looking for innovative ideas as long as they don’t conflict with yours, so your teen heartthrob soulmate is Mark Paul Gosselaar. He’s sweet and fun and can always help you when you need it most.
Pisces: Joey Lawrence
Your ability to multitask and empathize with anyone makes you an amazing partner, but you need someone who can be strong alongside you when you get distracted. Joey Lawrence is a great soulmate for you because he gets distracted enough himself that he probably won’t even notice when you aren’t paying attention!