Toys | Life

According To A Study, These Are The Most Popular 90s Toys In Each State

Flickr - Rona Proudfoot / Etsy - PastelEtPixel

When you think back to your childhood, what toy do you remember spending most of your time with?

There's probably one that stands out, whether it was a particular stuffed animal, a special Barbie, or even a video game, that you remember going absolutely bananas over.

Have you ever wondered if you were the only one to be completely obsessed with it, or if kids from other states also loved the same thing?

Well, AT&T has decided to dig into the world of 90s nostalgia, and they hope to answer the question we've all had, "What is the most popular toy in my state?"

Obviously, it was going to take a lot of work, and so they began examining shopping trends of the 90s and found out the most popular toy of the decade in each individual state.

Not only did they find out what toys were popular then, they also did a bit of an eBay deep-dive to find out how much those old classics are worth now.

Are you ready to find out your state's most popular toy? And which state had the same favorite toy as you?  

American Girl Doll – Average eBay price: $90

American Girl Dolls remain popular in more states than any other classic toy. They are the favorite in Connecticut, Illinois, Kansas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Mississippi, Pennsylvania, Utah, and Wisconsin.

Power Wheels – Average eBay price: $200

Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, South Carolina, and Tennessee all seem to love those cars that you can ride around in, and honestly we're a little jealous. Those things are awesome.

LEGO – Average eBay price: $25 - $3,000+ depending on the kit

In California, Montana, and New Mexico, kids appreciate the classic and creative Lego sets. But, the best thing is that you can still get so many awesome sets, including this big box of bricks to create whatever you want.

Fashion Plates – Average eBay price: $22

New Jersey and North Carolina seems to be filled with budding fashion designers, obsessed with planning out some new outfits.

Littlest Pet Shop – Average eBay price: $12

The kids in Alaska and Kentucky became obsessed with those tiny animals that you'd lose way too easily.

Baby Alive – Average eBay price: $120

In Oklahoma, kids were obsessed with that doll that could chew and needed you to change their diaper... Seriously.

Barbie – Average eBay price: $20

Shockingly enough, only West Virginia was cited as having Barbie as their most popular toy. I don't think she's too upset about it though, she's plenty popular. If you want this particular doll, you can find her for sale on Amazon along with a bunch of other classic retro dolls.

Betty Spaghetty – Average eBay price: $30

Ohio was really into the wacky and different Betty Spaghetty dolls that remained popular into the early 2000s.

Buzz Lightyear – Average eBay price: $40

The 90s wouldn't have been even half as good without Toy Story, so it's surprising that only Arkansas considered Buzz their favorite toy.

Crossfire – Average eBay price: $50

While I completely forgot this existed, Florida remembers this "Rapid-fire shoot-out" game fondly.

Don’t Wake Daddy – Average eBay price: $25

In Alabama kids apparently loved one of the weirdest board games ever. As weird as it is, you can still buy it new on Amazon.

Easy-Bake Oven – Average eBay price: $60

Wyoming loved those little individual-sized cakes that took one hundred years to cook because you were using a tiny little lightbulb.

Elefun – Average eBay price: $25

Even though their parents probably hated finding all those butterflies around the house, the kids of Missouri were obsessed with Elefun.

Floam – Average eBay price: $20 (up to $120 unopened 1994 purple Floam)

For some reason certain Floam colors are worth a crazy amount of money, but maybe it's because the kids of Hawaii are trying to get back what they once had.

Gameboy Advance – Average eBay price: $30

New Hampshire knows where it's at. Gameboys were the dream.

Gator Golf – Average eBay price: $30

While it might sound like something targeted at Florida, the real fan of Gator Golf was actually Texas.

Heelys – Average eBay price: $30

Don't try and stop the kids of North Dakota, because they are going to be zooming by on their roller-shoes before you can say anything. Kids today can still get them too, they are less than $20!

Koosh ball – Average eBay price: $6

The popularity of Koosh balls may have to do with Rosie O'Donnell's obsession with throwing them at her audience, or it may be because Oregon kids were completely frantic about collecting them.

Lite Brite – Average eBay price: $20

Idaho was home to a lot of creative kids who were maybe a little bit afraid of the dark. Don't worry guys, a lot of all over the country felt the same. You know what, even as an adult I kind of want one of these. Luckily they are still available brand new on Amazon.

Mr. Bucket – Average eBay price: $20

Kids from Nebraska were super entertained by Mr. Bucket. Seriously. No, I don't get it either.

Mr. Sketch – Average eBay price: $7

I probably wouldn't have counted this as a toy, as these markers were used in some pretty important kid business like book reports and poster board displays, but in Colorado all the kids needed to have scented markers. You can still buy them on Amazon too!

My Size Barbie – Average eBay price: $70

So while those regular-size Barbies were only popular in West Virginia, the kids in New York wanted the gigantic dolls. I guess they just really liked sharing her outfits.

Nerf Gun – Average eBay price: $40

Arizona was all about the Nerf gun fights, rumor has it they are still battling to this day.

Nintendo 64 – Average eBay price: $50

It's shocking to me that Vermont is the only state to fully appreciate the glory that is the Nintendo 64.

Perfection – Average eBay price: $10

I don't know why Michigan loves the game that gave so many of us an indescribable amount of anxiety, but I guess to each their own.

Pogs – Average eBay price: $2 – $40

Nevada kids were fans of the little cardboard disks, maybe because they used them to pretend they were making their own casino chips?

Polly Pockets – Average eBay price: $20

The kids in Washington appreciated the perfection that was the delicate and cute little Polly Pockets.

Power Rangers – Average eBay price: $7

The children of Maine became obsessed with Power Rangers toys, and you know what, that's a great choice. Good job Maine.

Skip It – Average eBay price: $30

Iowa kids love that exhausting cardio exercise that resulted in more bruised ankles than anything in the world. If you're ready to risk the next generations ankles, you can still buy Skip-It style toys on Amazon.

Socker Boppers – Average eBay price: $20

I guess the kids in Virginia had a bit of a violent streak that their parents needed to tend to.

Super Soaker – Average eBay price: $50

In the District of Columbia, kids are always reaching for their Super Soakers.

Tamagotchi – Average eBay price: $40

If you're in Delaware you may still see some of those 90s kids clutching their Tamagotchis in their hands, refusing to let them die. Good thing Tamagotchis are back on Amazon though, so if you did lose yours all those years ago, you can get a new one.

Tech Deck – Average eBay price: $15

Rhode Island was the home of the tiny skateboard. Going outside and using a real skateboard was maybe a little bit too dangerous, so instead let's play with these.

Trolls – Average eBay price: $15

And finally, South Dakota was the state where Trolls really swept the toy stores, with all the kids demanding those weird, big-haired, creatures for every occasion.

Source - All Home Connections

So, do you agree with your states most popular toy?

Just so you know, Throwbacks may collect a share of sales or other compensation from some of the links on this page. However, we only choose products we would or have purchased ourselves.

More Throwbacks

Retro

Toys 'R' Us Is Back For The Holidays - Here's How To Find Your Nearest Location

Since Toys 'R' Us filed for bankruptcy last September, Toys 'R' Us Kids of all ages have been anxiously following the struggling chains ups and downs.Last month, we shared the surprising news that investors planned to reopen the iconic toy store as a pop-up chain just in time for Christmas.Now, we know more about where these pop-up stores will be, including almost 600 locations in 30 states.Home For The HolidaysGeoffrey the Giraffe is the face of the new Geoffrey's Toy Box chain.KrogerOn Friday, Kroger, the country's largest supermarket chain, announced they would be opening

Toys

30 Toys From The Sears Wishbook We All Wanted Under Our Christmas Tree 30 Years Ago

I think we can all agree that one of the best things to do while growing up was digging through the Sears Wishbook to try and make our Christmas lists.It was around this time every year that we started to get really serious about it, even though Christmas was still a ways off. We obviously needed a lot of time to plan out our lists for Santa Claus, and we weren't about to make the same mistake as the year before and forget to send one! The Wishbook was an important part of that and while it may not

80s

10 Weebles Playsets From Our Childhoods We Loved To Watch Wobble

There were always toys when you were a kid that seemed to be more important than the rest. There were some that you couldn't go to bed without, there were others that you spent months begging your parents for, and then there were a few that were just staples, readily available where ever you went. No matter which friends house you were at or doctor's office waiting room you were in, there were some that just seemed to be everywhere. Weebles were one of the toys you would be mostly likely to find anywhere that toys were set up for

80s

With Sears Filing For Bankruptcy, Let's Never Forget How Amazing The Wish Book Was

If you celebrate Christmas, then you know that the most important and exciting day of the year is the one whenever your Sears Wish Book arrives. That's when you know that it's time to start writing out your Christmas list, comparing all the potential toys that you might consider. Pages and pages of Barbies, Lego, and board games to dream about, before writing them down on your letter to Santa. The Wish Book is one of those things that you never really stop looking at. You just keep on flipping through the pages any time you get bored, probably because

Toys

Toys 'R' Us Is Coming Back With A New Name, But Not Everyone Is Happy About It

Last week we learned that the lenders responsible for Toys 'R' Us had canceled their bankruptcy auction, meaning that they were planning on attempting a comeback. And already the company has revealed their new plans, but not everyone is happy about it. The Toys 'R' Us branding, including the name and mascots, were retained by the lenders. While the company couldn't make it work, the investors think they've figured out a way to make more money, and it involves bringing back the iconic giraffe. Geoffrey the Giraffe has been the Toys 'R' Us mascot for a long time, but now

Toys

Toys 'R' Us May Be Back In Business With Investors Planning A Revival

Remember how devastating it was just a few months ago when Toys 'R' Us filed for bankruptcy and shut all their doors in America? It was like a piece of our childhood had died and we could do nothing but sit and watch it happen. No more biking through the aisles, no more seeing walls of Lego sets, and no more setting off all of the noisy toys at once before running away. Sure, the employees hated us all, but it was a part of growing up, and it was sad to think that the children of the future wouldn't